10 Best Self Tanners for Your Face That Leave You Glowing, Not Orange

You're on the hunt for a self tanner that will give your face a natural, sun-kissed glow without leaving you looking like an Oompa Loompa, and our top 10 picks are sure to leave you feeling confident and radiant. From clean, vegan formulas to lightweight lotions and easy-to-use drops, these self tanners cater to a range of skin tones and preferences. Whether you're looking for a gradual, buildable color or a quick, streak-free tan, these products promise to deliver a healthy, natural-looking glow. Keep reading to discover the perfect self tanner for your face.

Key Takeaways

• Choose a self-tanner specifically formulated for the face to avoid breakouts and ensure a natural-looking, streak-free glow.
• Opt for self-tanners with clean, vegan, and cruelty-free ingredients to minimize the risk of skin irritation or allergic reactions.
• Look for buildable formulas that allow for a gradual, customizable tan to achieve your desired level of bronze.
• Consider your skin tone when selecting a self-tanner shade to ensure a natural, sun-kissed look without appearing orange.
• Properly prep your skin by exfoliating and moisturizing before applying the self-tanner for an even, long-lasting result.

Beauty by Earth Self Tanner Mousse – Fair to Medium

If you're looking for a clean, vegan self tanner that provides a natural, buildable bronze glow, we recommend trying Beauty by Earth Self Tanner Mousse in Fair to Medium.

This quick-acting formula can give you a sun-kissed look in just a few hours, and it's made with clean, toxin-free ingredients.

We love that it's available in different shades and sizes, so you can find the perfect match for your skin tone and lifestyle.

For best results, use it with the Beauty by Earth Self Tanning Mitt & Application Kit, and work in small sections to guarantee an even, streak-free application.

You can even apply baby powder to certain areas to avoid stickiness.

Users rave about the natural-looking color that lasts for about a week.

Best For: Those seeking a clean, vegan self tanner that provides a natural-looking, buildable bronze glow.

Pros:

• Made with clean, toxin-free ingredients and available in different shades and sizes
• Quick-acting formula that can provide a sun-kissed look in just a few hours
• Users report a natural-looking color that lasts for about a week

Cons:

• May require the use of additional products, like the Beauty by Earth Self Tanning Mitt & Application Kit, for best results
• Some users may find the slight fragrance detectable by others
• The tan may fade more quickly with sweating or other activities

Loving Tan Deluxe Face Tan, Medium (1.6 Fl Oz)

For those seeking a streak-free, natural-looking tan on their face and neck, we recommend Loving Tan's Deluxe Face Tan in Medium.

This lightweight, gentle lotion is formulated with premium, naturally derived ingredients to give you a healthy, sun-kissed glow without exposing your skin to harmful UV rays.

We love that it's designed to match Loving Tan's popular mousses and gradual tanners, so you can achieve a seamless, all-over tan.

With 10+ applications per bottle, it's a great value, and the cruelty-free, dermatologist-tested formula means you can feel good about using it.

While some users find the color a bit yellow and the consistency oily, most agree it blends well and effectively masks hyperpigmentation for a more even complexion.

Best For: Those seeking a streak-free, natural-looking tan on their face and neck without sun exposure.

Pros:

• Lightweight, gentle formula with naturally derived ingredients
• Provides a healthy, sun-kissed glow that matches Loving Tan's other products
• Cruelty-free and dermatologist-tested

Cons:

• Some users find the color a bit yellow and the consistency oily
• May not be as long-lasting as body self-tanners
• Color may fade quickly and require daily application to maintain results

Isle of Paradise Self Tanning Drops, 1.01 Fl Oz

Those seeking a natural, gradual glow on their very pale skin will appreciate Isle of Paradise's color correcting self tanning drops.

We love how easily these drops mix with our daily moisturizer for an even, velvety application that doesn't leave us looking patchy or orange.

Starting with just a subtle tan, we can build up to our desired level of depth by using 1-5 drops per application.

The result is a healthy, 'brown as a berry' glow that's long-lasting and easy to maintain.

We've found these drops work particularly well for the face and neck, but it's important to blend properly to avoid spotting.

Pair with the brand's tan correcting water spray for a complete, tropical-inspired look that's perfect for sensitive skin.

Best For: Those with very pale skin seeking a natural, gradual, and easily customizable self-tanning solution.

Pros:

• Mixes well with moisturizer for an even, velvety application
• Buildable color, allowing for a subtle to deep tan
• Long-lasting and easy to maintain glow

Cons:

• Requires proper blending to avoid spotting or patchiness
• Can appear orange if over-applied
• May not provide immediate results for those seeking a quick, deep tan

Botanic Tree Self Tanning Lotion for Face and Body

We recommend Botanic Tree Self Tanning Lotion for those seeking a plant-based, organic bronzer that provides a streak-free, natural-looking tan without the risks of UV exposure or harsh chemicals.

It's made in the USA, cruelty-free, and packed with nourishing ingredients like Shea Butter and 10 organic fruit extracts to hydrate and rejuvenate your skin while you bronze.

The fast-absorbing formula won't stain your clothes or leave dark spots on your towels, and it's suitable for fair to dark skin tones.

While some customers rave about the realistic results, others have had issues with streaking or uneven application, so be sure to exfoliate well, apply a thin layer, and blend thoroughly for the best outcome.

With a little practice, you'll be glowing in no time!

Best For: Those seeking a natural-looking, streak-free tan using a plant-based, organic formula that hydrates and rejuvenates skin.

Pros:

• Cruelty-free, made in the USA, and free of parabens and toxic chemicals
• Fast-absorbing formula won't stain clothes or leave dark spots on towels
• Suitable for fair to dark skin tones, providing a sun-kissed look

Cons:

• Some customers experienced issues with streaking or uneven application
• Requires thorough exfoliation and careful blending for best results
• Formula may have changed over time, leading to inconsistent performance

St. Tropez Self Tan Purity Face Mist, 2.7 Fl Oz

Pale-skinned beauties, especially redheads, will adore the natural, sunkissed glow that St. Tropez's vegan and cruelty-free Self Tan Purity Face Mist effortlessly delivers. Infused with hyaluronic acid and antioxidants, this face mist is a breeze to apply—just spritz it on your face and neck, and you're good to go! We love how it lasts for about three days, giving us a subtle, healthy-looking radiance that's perfect for everyday wear.

The pleasant grapefruit-like scent is a nice touch, and the tan itself lasts for one to two days before needing a refresh.

While some users may experience breakouts or notice a self-tanner odor post-application, we've found that starting with just a few sprays and applying moisturizer once the mist dries helps mitigate these issues.

Best For: Those with pale skin, especially redheads, who desire a natural-looking, sunkissed glow without the hassle of complicated application processes.

Pros:

• Vegan, cruelty-free, and infused with hyaluronic acid and antioxidants for a healthy-looking radiance
• Easy to apply, simply spritz on face and neck for a subtle, even glow
• Pleasant grapefruit-like scent and long-lasting results (up to 3 days)

Cons:

• May cause breakouts for some users with sensitive skin
• Can leave a noticeable self-tanner odor after application
• Multiple applications may result in an orange or uneven appearance

L'Oreal Paris Sublime Bronze Self Tanning Facial Drops, 1 fl. oz

L'Oreal's fragrance-free self-tanning drops are a top pick for anyone seeking a natural-looking, buildable facial tan without the risk of breakouts or irritation.

We love that these drops can be mixed with your favorite moisturizer, allowing you to customize the intensity of your glow. Whether you're after a subtle sun-kissed look or a deeper bronze, these versatile drops have you covered.

They're formulated with hyaluronic acid to keep your skin hydrated and smooth, and users rave about the streak-free, natural-looking results.

The only caution? Men might experience some temporary beard reddening, and proper blending is key to avoid unevenness. But overall, these drops are a game-changer for achieving a healthy, radiant complexion without the need for makeup or sun damage.

Best For: Anyone seeking a natural-looking, buildable facial tan without the risk of breakouts or irritation.

Pros:

• Fragrance-free formula suitable for sensitive skin
• Customizable intensity by mixing with moisturizer
• Contains hyaluronic acid for added hydration

Cons:

• May cause temporary beard reddening in men
• Requires careful blending to avoid uneven application
• Needs daily reapplication to maintain desired tan level

Self Tan Brush for Body & Leg Makeup (Rose Gold)

For those seeking an essential makeup tool that smooths skin and creates an airbrush effect, the Self Tan Brush for Body & Leg Makeup in rose gold is a must-have. It's made with ultra-fine, soft, high-density synthetic bristles that are non-shedding and durable.

We love the shiny ABS plastic handle that's tightly connected for a secure grip.

The curved shape of the bristles is designed for refined makeup application, making it perfect for applying tanning sunscreen, body lotion, foundation, and more.

At 7.6 x 6.8cm / 3 x 2.7 inches, it's the ideal size for easy handling and portability. Whether you're using it for daily makeup, travel, or keeping it in your gym bag or purse, this versatile brush has got you covered.

Best For: Anyone looking for a high-quality, versatile makeup brush to apply tanning sunscreen, body lotion, foundation, and more with a smooth, airbrush effect.

Pros:

• Ultra-fine, soft, high-density synthetic bristles for a flawless application
• Curved shape of the bristles allows for refined makeup application
• Compact size makes it perfect for daily use, travel, or on-the-go touch-ups

Cons:

• May not be suitable for those with very sensitive skin
• Rose gold color may not appeal to everyone's personal style preferences
• Some users may prefer a larger brush size for faster application on larger areas of the body

Coco & Eve Antioxidant Face Tanning Micromist (2.54 fl oz)

Whether you have dry, oily, or sensitive skin, we've found the ultimate self-tanner that delivers a natural-looking glow while nourishing your skin with antioxidants and hydration – introducing Coco & Eve's Antioxidant Face Tanning Micromist.

This innovative 2-in-1 product not only gives you a perfect sun-kissed look, but it also boosts collagen production and hydration with its antioxidant complex and Hyalurosmooth.

The lightweight micromist technology guarantees a foolproof, even application every time. Just spritz, wait, and glow! Plus, the tropical scent, featuring notes of Peach Coconut Water, Coconut Frangipani Flower, and Vanilla Solar Accord, will transport you to a paradise getaway.

With 25,000 units sold in just 3 weeks, customers are raving about the long-lasting, natural-looking results.

Best For: Those looking for a foolproof, nourishing self-tanner that delivers a natural-looking glow while pampering the skin with antioxidants and hydration.

Pros:

• 2-in-1 product that combines self-tanning with skincare benefits
• Innovative micromist technology ensures even, smooth application
• Suitable for all skin types, including dry, oily, and sensitive

Cons:

• Product size may be small for the price point
• Scent, while pleasant, may be strong for some users
• Multiple applications may be needed to achieve desired tan depth

b.tan Darkest Self Tan Drops for Face & Body

Always on the lookout for a natural-looking, bronzed glow, we were excited to try b.tan's Darkest Self Tan Drops for Face & Body.

These vegan, cruelty-free drops are formulated with hydrating hyaluronic acid and vitamin E to deeply moisturize as they tan.

We love how versatile they're – you can add them to your daily moisturizer, serum, or self-tanner for a customizable bronzing boost.

The directions suggest applying daily for 3 days initially, then maintaining with use every 2-3 days.

In our experience, these drops give a beautiful bronze hue without any orange or fake undertones. They're moisturizing, long-lasting, and don't streak.

The only downsides? The bottle can run out quickly, and there's a noticeable scent.

But overall, we're impressed!

Best For: Those seeking a natural-looking, bronzed glow with a hydrating, streak-free formula.

Pros:

• Versatile and customizable, can be added to moisturizers, serums, or self-tanners
• Provides a beautiful bronze hue without orange or fake undertones
• Moisturizing and long-lasting formula

Cons:

• Bottle can run out quickly
• Noticeable scent
• May not provide a deep, dark tan for some users

Isle of Paradise Self Tanning Drops, 1.01 Fl Oz

Isle of Paradise's Self Tanning Drops provide a simple, customizable solution for those seeking a gradual, natural-looking tan on their face without the risk of patchiness or uneven application.

We love that these vegan, cruelty-free drops mix effortlessly with our daily moisturizer, allowing us to build up to our desired level of tan by using 1-5 drops per application.

The color-correcting formula guarantees a subtle, healthy glow that's perfect for even the palest complexions.

While it's important to blend properly to avoid spotting, we've found that these drops apply evenly with a velvety face mitt, leaving us with a long-lasting, tropical tan that's easy to maintain.

Whether you're a self-tanning novice or a seasoned pro, Isle of Paradise's Self Tanning Drops are a must-try for achieving that coveted, sun-kissed look.

Best For: Those seeking a gradual, natural-looking, and customizable self-tanning solution for their face and neck.

Pros:

• Vegan, cruelty-free formula that mixes well with daily moisturizer
• Color-correcting drops provide a subtle, healthy glow suitable for pale skin
• Long-lasting, easy-to-maintain tan that applies evenly with a face mitt

Cons:

• Requires proper blending to avoid spotting or uneven application
• Possible to over-apply, resulting in an orange appearance
• May not provide desired results for those seeking a more intense, immediate tan

Factors to Consider When Choosing a Self Tanner for Face

When you're searching for the perfect self tanner for your face, there are several key factors to bear in mind.

You'll want to think about your skin type compatibility, the ease of application, and the quality of ingredients used in the formula.

It's also important to ponder the desired tanning result, as well as the scent and feel of the product on your skin.

Skin Type Compatibility

To select the perfect facial self-tanner, you'll need to evaluate your skin type and any specific concerns you may have.

If you've got dry skin, look for self-tanners that contain hydrating ingredients like glycerin or hyaluronic acid, which will help keep your skin moisturized while giving you that sun-kissed glow.

On the other hand, if you're prone to oiliness, opt for oil-free or mattifying formulas to avoid that dreaded midday shine.

For those of you with sensitive skin, it's essential to choose a gentle, fragrance-free self-tanner to minimize the risk of irritation. Trust me, you don't want to end up with a patchy, red complexion instead of a beautiful bronze!

If you've got fair skin, remember to select lighter, buildable shades to prevent an unnatural, overly dark appearance.

The key is to find a self-tanner that works harmoniously with your unique skin type and addresses any specific issues you may have. By taking these factors into consideration, you'll be well on your way to achieving a flawless, natural-looking tan that leaves you feeling confident and radiant.

Application Ease

Achieving a flawless, even tan on your face hinges upon the ease of application, so selecting a self-tanner that meshes seamlessly with your routine is crucial. You'll want to look for formulas that are lightweight and absorb quickly into your skin, ensuring a streak-free finish without any fuss. Self-tanning drops or mists can be a game-changer, allowing you to apply the product precisely where you need it, without any guesswork.

When it comes to achieving that perfect sun-kissed glow, the last thing you want is a self-tanner that leaves your skin feeling sticky or greasy. Opting for products that dry quickly is important, so you can get on with your day without any awkward waiting around.

With the right tools and a little bit of know-how, you'll be rocking a natural-looking, effortless tan in no time, leaving everyone wondering if you've just returned from a tropical vacation. And if you're worried about those telltale marks around your hairline or jawline, consider using a brush or applicator mitt to help distribute the product evenly.

Ingredient Quality

Your face deserves the best, so scrutinizing self-tanner ingredient lists is a necessity to guarantee you're nourishing your skin with clean, gentle formulas. Look for self-tanners that feature natural, skin-loving ingredients like DHA, aloe vera, and botanical extracts. These components work together to gradually build a beautiful, sun-kissed glow while keeping your delicate facial skin happy and healthy.

Steer clear of self-tanners loaded with harsh chemicals, parabens, and artificial fragrances that can irritate your skin or clog your pores. Instead, prioritize formulas that are vegan, cruelty-free, and free of synthetic additives and dyes. Your face will thank you for choosing products that align with your values and keep your skin's best interests in mind.

Don't forget to check for self-tanners infused with nourishing ingredients like hyaluronic acid and vitamin E. These skin-saviors help to hydrate, plump, and condition your complexion while you achieve that coveted golden glow.

And if redness or unevenness is a concern, consider self-tanners with color-correcting properties that can help neutralize these issues, leaving you with a flawless, radiant finish.

Tanning Result

When selecting a self-tanner for your face, the tanning result should be a top priority to guarantee you achieve a natural-looking, sun-kissed glow that complements your complexion. You'll want to steer clear of formulas that leave you looking like an Oompa Loompa, and instead, opt for self-tanners that provide a buildable, gradual tan. Look for products that promise a natural, realistic color without any orange undertones or artificial-looking streaks.

Consider self-tanning drops or mousses that allow you to control the intensity of your tan, so you can start subtle and build up to your desired level of bronze. These formulas are perfect for achieving an even, seamless glow that looks like you've just returned from a tropical vacation.

Don't forget to choose a self-tanner specifically designed for your face to avoid any irritation or clogged pores. With the right product, you'll be rocking a radiant, golden complexion that leaves everyone wondering if you've been soaking up the sun (without any of the harmful UV damage, of course!).

Scent and Feel

Though often overlooked, the scent and feel of your facial self-tanner can make or break your tanning experience. You'll want to choose a product with a minimal or pleasant fragrance to avoid any overpowering scents or odors that could be off-putting. Strong chemical smells can interfere with the overall tanning process and leave you feeling less than refreshed.

When it comes to texture, opt for a lightweight, fast-absorbing formula that doesn't leave a sticky or greasy residue on your skin. A smooth, non-drying formula will provide a more natural-looking result and feel comfortable throughout the day.

Pay attention to the application ease as well, as this can greatly impact your tanning experience.

Frequently Asked Questions

How Long Does a Self Tanner Typically Last on the Face?

Like a summer romance, your self-tanner's glow on your face can last anywhere from 3 to 7 days. To maintain that sun-kissed look, you'll need to reapply the product every few days.

Can Self Tanners Cause Breakouts or Clog Pores on the Face?

Yes, some self-tanners can clog pores and cause breakouts if they're not non-comedogenic. To avoid this, choose oil-free, non-comedogenic formulas suitable for your skin type. Always cleanse your face thoroughly before and after applying self-tanner.

Are Self Tanners Safe to Use on Sensitive Facial Skin?

Sensitive skin? Seek self tanners specifically suited for your delicate face. Opt for organic, oil-free options with soothing ingredients like aloe vera. Always do a patch test and follow instructions for a glowing, not irritated, complexion.

How Can You Avoid Streaks or Uneven Application on the Face?

To avoid streaks or uneven application on your face, exfoliate first to remove dead skin. Use a small amount of self-tanner and blend thoroughly, especially around hairline and jawline. Wash your hands after application.

Can You Apply Regular Moisturizer or Makeup Over Facial Self Tanner?

Like icing on a cake, you can absolutely apply moisturizer and makeup over facial self tanner. Just wait until the tanner is fully absorbed to avoid streaking. Then layer on your favorite products for a flawless finish.